Western Michigan at Toledo Week 4 College Football Matchup Western Michigan at Toledo Matchup - Week 4
Sat, Sep 23 2023 · Week 4 · 🏟 Glass Bowl Toledo, OH · Turf · 26,248 cap
Western Michigan✈ 110 miSame TZ
31 49
Final
Home
📊 Punt & Rally Projection
Western Michigan
17
Toledo
37
P&R Line Toledo -20
P&R Total O/U 53.5
Confidence 86 High
Vegas Toledo -21.5 · O/U 52.5
Matchup Prediction
Toledo has the edge in this matchup
Both Momentum Control (CSS) and Game Control metrics favor Toledo entering this game.
Momentum Control
71.6%
Toledo wins
Solid
Game Control
58.6%
Toledo wins
Lean
Vegas Spread
Toledo -21.5
O/U 52.5
William Hill (New Jersey)
Advanced Stats
PPA + Success Rate agree → Toledo · 73.9% ATS historically
↓ See full breakdown
🏠 Toledo 3rd straight Home Game 🚌 Western Michigan 3rd straight Road Game
Western Michigan 2023 Schedule
Western Michigan's 2023 Schedule
DateMatchupSpreadTotalResultO/UCover
Thu 8/31Western Michigan vs St. Francis (PA)-14.0W35–1758.0W35–17UY
Sat 9/9Western Michigan at Syracuse+24.5L7–4856.5L7–48UN
Sat 9/16Western Michigan at Iowa+28.5L10–4143.5L10–41ON
Sat 9/23Western Michigan at Toledo+21.5L31–4952.5L31–49OY
Sat 9/30Western Michigan vs Ball State-1.5W42–2450.0W42–24OY
Sat 10/7Western Michigan at Mississippi State+21.5L28–4154.5L28–41OY
Sat 10/14Western Michigan vs Miami (OH)+7.5L21–3446.0L21–34ON
Sat 10/21Western Michigan at Ohio+16.5L17–2052.0L17–20UY
Sat 10/28Western Michigan at Eastern Michigan-3.0W45–2150.0W45–21OY
— Bye Week —
Tue 11/7Western Michigan vs Central Michigan-3.5W38–2857.5W38–28OY
Tue 11/14Western Michigan at Northern Illinois+4.5L0–2455.5L0–24UN
Tue 11/21Western Michigan vs Bowling Green+2.0L10–3454.5L10–34UN
Toledo 2023 Schedule
Toledo's 2023 Schedule
DateMatchupSpreadTotalResultO/UCover
Sat 9/2Toledo at Illinois+7.0L28–3045.5L28–30OY
Sat 9/9Toledo vs Texas Southern-40.5W71–361.0W71–3OY
Sat 9/16Toledo vs San José State-9.0W21–1756.5W21–17UN
Sat 9/23Toledo vs Western Michigan-21.5W49–3152.5W49–31ON
Sat 9/30Toledo vs Northern Illinois-13.0W35–3348.0W35–33ON
Sat 10/7Toledo at Massachusetts-19.0W41–2455.5W41–24ON
Sat 10/14Toledo at Ball State-17.5W13–648.5W13–6UN
Sat 10/21Toledo at Miami (OH)-2.0W21–1746.5W21–17UY
— Bye Week —
Tue 10/31Toledo vs Buffalo-14.0W31–1347.0W31–13UY
Wed 11/8Toledo vs Eastern Michigan-19.5W49–2345.5W49–23OY
Tue 11/14Toledo at Bowling Green-9.5W32–3148.5W32–31ON
Fri 11/24Toledo at Central Michigan-12.5W32–1754.5W32–17UY
Sat 12/2Toledo vs Miami (OH)-8.5L14–2346.0L14–23UN
Sat 12/30Toledo vs Wyoming+4.5L15–1643.5L15–16UY
Advanced Stats
Advanced Analytics Matchup
Matchup-adjusted (offense vs opponent defense) · 2023 season
Toledo PPA Edge
Agreement Signals — When All Metrics Agree
Elite · 83.1% ATS
PPA + PPO + SR + Havoc
Split
Metrics disagree
Elite · 82.4% ATS
PPA + PPO + Havoc
Split
Metrics disagree
Elite · 73.9% ATS
PPA + Success Rate
Both Agree
→ Toledo
Individual Factors — Ranked by Predictive Strength
PPA Overall
Points added per play · Elite predictor
Western Michigan #85
+0.261
Toledo #27
+0.500
Toledo Edge
PPA Passing
Pass efficiency edge · Strong predictor
Western Michigan #96
+0.320
Toledo #24
+0.753
Toledo Edge
Havoc Total
Def. disruption rate · Strong predictor
Western Michigan #13
0.194
Toledo #43
0.174
TFLs, sacks, PBUs, forced fumbles — higher is better
Western Michigan Edge
Points Per Opp
Drive-finishing edge · Strong predictor
Western Michigan #72
+7.214
Toledo #26
+8.592
Toledo Edge
Success Rate
Play consistency edge · Solid predictor
Western Michigan #90
+0.786
Toledo #34
+0.895
Toledo Edge
Field Position
Avg start (lower=better) · Solid predictor
Western Michigan #101
71.7
Toledo #25
69.0
Avg yards from own endzone to average start — lower is better · longer bar = better field position
Toledo Edge
Advanced stats sourced from CFBD · 2023 season · Edges are matchup-adjusted (offense vs opponent defense)
Power Ratings
Team Power Ratings
Overall · Offense · Defense ratings · Updated as season progresses
Toledo Rated Higher
Overall Power Rating
Western Michigan
-5.3
Toledo
1.8
Offense Rating
Western Michigan
14.5
Toledo
15.8
Defense Rating (lower = better defense)
Western Michigan
19.9
Toledo
13.9
Power ratings updated throughout the season as results accumulate
Momentum Control (CSS)
Consecutive Scoring Sequences Who builds scoring momentum? Toledo Edge
Avg sequences created per game
Western Michigan #114
0.00
Toledo #34
1.50
Avg sequences allowed per game (lower is better)
Western Michigan #94
3.50
Toledo #5
0.50
Toledo +1.50
CSS Edge (season-to-date)
Teams with this edge win 71.6% of games historically
Based on 2 games this season
Game Control (GC)
Win Probability Dominance Who controls games start to finish? Toledo Edge
Avg GC score per game (offense)
Western Michigan #1
38.8
Toledo #1
48.4
Avg GC score allowed per game (lower is better)
Western Michigan #103
47.7
Toledo #23
35.9
Toledo +9.6
GC Edge (season-to-date)
Teams with this edge win 58.6% of games historically
Based on 3 games this season
Actual Result
CSS Battle
Toledo
3 — 1 sequences
✓ Predicted correctly
GC Battle
Toledo
39.3 — 36.3 GC score
✓ Predicted correctly
Game Result
Toledo won by 18
✓ Model called it
Spread Context
ATS Historical Context
Based on 2021–2025 backtest · FBS vs FBS · Regular season

Both metrics agree on Toledo. Teams with this edge profile have covered 50.3% historically — essentially a coin flip against the spread.

ATS data is informational only. Past cover rates do not guarantee future results.

Coaching Matchup
Western Michigan
Lance Taylor #1
1–2 (33%) · Yr 1 at school
OC Billy Cosh Yr 1 #1
DC Lou Esposito Yr 3 #1
Staff Rating
0.00 #1
Toledo
Jason Candle #1
56–33 (63%) · Yr 8 at school
OC Mike Hallett Yr 3 #1
DC Vince Kehres Yr 3 #1
Staff Rating
0.00 #1
About these metrics
Advanced Stats shows matchup-adjusted factor edges (offense vs opponent defense). Combination signals — when PPA, PPO, Success Rate, and Havoc all point the same direction — have historically predicted the SU winner in 95–97% of games and the ATS winner in 82–83% of games (2021–2025, FBS vs FBS, regular season).
Impact: Advanced Stats are the best performance based metric used to predict the outcome of games.

Momentum Control (CSS) measures consecutive scoring sequences — when a team scores, holds the opponent scoreless, then scores again. Teams entering a game with a CSS edge of +1.0 or more have won 71–78% of games historically (2021–2025, FBS vs FBS).
Impact: CSS is not a predictive ATS advantage, data shows this is already considered when lines are set.

Game Control (GC) measures win probability dominance — how thoroughly a team controlled the game from start to finish. Teams with a GC edge of +12 or more have won 67–76% of games historically. When both metrics agree, combined confidence is higher. When they split, treat as a lean at best.
Impact: GS is not a predictive ATS advantage, data shows this is already considered when lines are set.

Power Ratings are a custom-built composite of a Teams Talent, Experience & Production, Coaching & Performance Metrics. These are updated constantly with roster changes, performance once the games start for the 2026 season, injuries the team is dealing with and scheduling situations.
Impact: There are a wide range of power ratings available, we think ours is the best, you can decide for yourself